- A new analysis determined that highly engineered consumables are potentially as addictive as tobacco products.
- Scientists discovered that these foods are formulated to maximize reward and hasten the delivery of reinforcing ingredients.
- The “addictive” property of these foods means they fuel compulsive consumption and interfere with natural hunger cues.
- The researchers propose that UPFs should be governed by controls similar to those for cigarettes.
Currently, there is not a universal definition of ultraprocessed foods. Some people describe them as foods that contain additives you would not find in a personal cupboard, such as emulsifiers and additives.
Numerous experts rely on the NOVA classification to identify ultraprocessed foods. This describes products that contain “formulations of ingredients, mostly of exclusive industrial use, typically made by a range of industrial techniques and processes.”
A recent analysis published in The Millbank Quarterly suggested that ultraprocessed foods could be just as habit-forming as cigarettes.
“It is my view with these findings, as ultra-processed foods are specifically engineered to be incredibly tempting to many consumers,” stated a weight loss specialist independent from the study.
Data from last year suggests that more than 73% of the foods available in the US is classified as ultraprocessed.
“Cigarettes and UPFs are not simply whole foods but highly engineered consumable products designed specifically to maximize physical and mental reinforcement and repeated intake,” explained the review’s scientists.
Can UPFs Habit-Forming?
This analysis synthesized data from substance use, historical health policy, and dietary science to highlight textural and compositional characteristics that increase the rewarding nature of both cigarettes and UPFs.
“It’s not all people is ‘hooked’ to such products, but for a sizable group, they elicit classic habit-forming patterns: strong cravings, inability to stop, and continued use despite negative health effects,” said a heart health nutrition expert.
“These products are purposely formulated with processed carbohydrates, extra oils, salt, and flavor enhancers to maximize reward and repeat consumption, and the industry uses persuasive advertising strategies, especially aimed at children,” she continued.
Scientists examined several important factors:
- rapid absorption
- pleasure-based design, or creating products to be extremely pleasurable
- dose optimization
- widespread availability
- deceptive reformulation, or “wellness branding”
The study concluded that, like tobacco, ultraprocessed foods are carefully calibrated to deliver the right dose of sugar.
“Refined carbohydrates stimulate dopamine release via the a key neural pathway, while lipids achieve this via intestinal lipid sensing,” the authors explained.
“… Ultraprocessed foods with significant amounts of refined carbohydrates and added fats are among the most strongly reinforcing substances in the contemporary food supply. It is key that this refined carbohydrate-fat mix is rarely found in whole foods.”
How such products rapidly introduce “pleasure-inducing” substances to the mind renders them likely habit-forming, in a comparable way to tobacco.
The paper stated that while cigarettes are designed to provide nicotine quickly, ultraprocessed foods are formulated to rapidly digest and absorb, as they typically have little to no fiber. This allows for the system to metabolize fat and sugar faster.
The researchers also explain that UPFs give intentional intense tastes that dissipate rapidly and textures that dissolve easily. This all helps to deliver increased pleasure signals and prompts individuals to eat more.
‘Health Washing’ in Tobacco, Ultraprocessed Foods
Based on the review, both the cigarette and food sectors have historically employed a tactic called “wellness branding.”
This refers to where products are marketed and reformulated to create an perception of less danger while preserving the essential addictive qualities.
This tactic in the cigarette sector became popular in the mid-20th century with the advent of filter tips on cigarettes.
They were sold as protective innovations that would catch tar and particles before they reached the respiratory system. Actually, these tips offer minimal meaningful protection.
Yet, people often adapted by taking bigger puffs or increasing consumption, which offset any decrease in harmful intake.
The food industry has taken a comparable strategy. It employs packaging claims like “reduced fat” or “no sugar added” to promote UPFs.
Yet, these foods often retain the same addictive formulations. The problem is that these reformulations offer a superficial impression of health while the product’s habit-forming nature and metabolic harms persist unchanged.
Should Ultraprocessed Foods Be Regulated?
The authors noted at the conclusion of their paper that food and tobacco are not the same thing.
Still, they cautioned that certain UPFs act like engineered consumables rather than real nourishment. They proposed that health regulations should reflect this reality.
“Tobacco offers a cautionary tale, and smoking regulations provides a model of hope,” the researchers wrote.
Because of regulations, smoking levels in the US have fallen and have “reshaped cultural views of tobacco and diminished trust in the industry.”
“I believe greater education about the harmful effects of ultra-processed foods is essential to reduce general consumption and enhance public health. The approaches employed to curb cigarette use have been successful and could be a useful blueprint for UPFs as well,” commented one expert.
“I don’t think ultraprocessed foods should be regulated precisely like tobacco, but they do warrant more robust, tobacco-inspired policies: advertising limits, obvious packaging warnings, stricter rules on wellness assertions, and limits in educational institutions or hospitals,” noted another nutrition professional.
The authors reminded people that lightly altered and whole foods have sustained our well-being for millennia.